Often its easy to point out what we don't like in books, or movies. On the same note its easy to forget to mention what we do like about them. Here's a quick overview of why GOT, or the Song of fire and Ice series, is that good. Starting with the top 6 reasons.
This is mostly spoiler free- No references to specifics within the plot are given. You should be safe to read it if you haven't already finished the series.
What this book does right
(6) Everything is Important but How Much So ?
This book has the ability to the separate interesting elements that are all important but the degree to which they are, is to be deciphered . In some cases there's a purposeful lapse, of some new information, a curious side note were you might wonder of the significance of and its place within the story. Its at these times when the Author George R.R. Martin (GRRM) is almost toying with the reader, occasionally hinting that some of those briefly mentioned rumors or insights can be significant while others could be purposefully misleading. This introduces a great deal of mystery. To compound this even more, the characters often express questionably relevant story elements within their own perspective, which is fallible at that ! This ups the ante even more as the reader lingers over an element introduced by those characters, and has to examine the characters disposition and motivations (which are thoroughly developed ) to ponder the relevancy and the validity of their statements. To good
(5) Depth of Character, Characters that Live and Breathe.
Character development and depth of personality is astounding well done. You could subject almost any of the cast to a Myers-Briggs test, and come out with a consistent personality type. Actions and events are foreshadowed just within knowledge of the persona's of the characters themselves. Even more intriguing GRRM has given many of these characters, their own chapters to feature their perspectives. Within these perspectives we get something vital to a good story -character flaws. For much of the book, Its not the events and the locations that drives the story's but the beautiful inevitability of complex characters, clashing ideals, and vocations scrimmaging in all out tragic Neo-Shakespearean manner.
Before this, just when the characters and plot rear into a gut wrenching climax ; those few moments preceding is when they're offered the choice to opt out, to escape ! The reader so desperately attached to these characters, longing and now yelling out at their ruffed up paperback copies, to take them ! These escapes sounds so good to, for everyone expect the characters themselves, and always sealed with that fatal flaw their fates are as inevitable as more burnt tossed then re-bought copies, of the book itself.
(4) Logic.
There is something very beautiful about logic. The placement consistency and ability to find a framework to express ideas, becomes all to rich in times where the form is as beautiful as the figure within it. The story is imbued with both character logic, (characters that act in dictates within their own personalities, and plot logic- (the ability for sides to act knowingly based on exclusive interests). This is so prevalent, that sometime after finishing the first book, I made a prediction based where I saw the story progressing. The waring or reconciliation of certain factions, it was, and to this end I predicted a particular and odd event that would have to happen to a character for this to come about. (Yes I'm involved in some sort of wacky interpretative dance/work-about to keep this spoiler free) This event on the outsets sounded and seemed both spectacular and random. Then when the event did occur later on, it only confirmed the layers of thought that went into this prediction were based on a long chain of casualty that the author would not forgo ! It wasn't so random! There is significant, deliberation in the outline of the plot bringing together elements that transforms narrative, naturally with a consistency and an affinity to its form.
(3) Plot Twists.
With logical consistency the characters, plot, story and world become much more believable. The incredible plot twist live within this logic, are foreshadowed within its form while still managing to surprise and shock the reader. That is, while sitting on the edge of your chair screaming "Holy" expletive "How", (stutter). "Why did that happen": It is after these not so calm moments, when you force yourself to settle down afterwards, to recollect your thoughts and say, "Yeah I knew it all along, the clues were there". Yet it ties in so well, with such a delicious sense of timing that its unraveling is unreal. This series of books has some of the best plot twists ever written in Fantasy.
(2) Strong Female Characters.
It almost goes without saying, when reading a fantasy novel you can expect a good deal of misogyny. Often times, it is argued as a consequence of "the times of the book", or the inexperience of the authors with the opposite sex. (Fantasy writers are not exactly rock stars). That's why it is so refreshing to witness such powerful engaging multidimensional female characters. Written in a way, with such a spectacle, that you could only think of Homers (the blind Greek author's) vivid pictorial depictions of battle glory as equally astounding . I should probably stop here, I just implicated the whole lot of fantasy writers as horse in carriage blindsided to the opposite sex. In many ways though the female characters are equal to if not better developed then any of their male counterparts. GRRM does really well in depicting characters that resound with readers regardless of their sex.
Finally the most Important reason why these books are that good
1) Bad-Ass Midgets
Yeah